Justia Entertainment & Sports Law Opinion Summaries

Sydney Walton, a fourteen-year-old, suffered a concussion and other head injuries during an indoor soccer practice at a Baltimore County-owned facility. The plaintiffs, her family, alleged that the defendants, including Premier Soccer Club, Inc., its coach, and several Baltimore County employees, were negligent in violating a Maryland statute designed to ensure that parents, players, and coaches in youth sports are informed about the risks of concussions and best practices for preventing and handling them.The Circuit Court for Baltimore County granted summary judgment in favor of the defendants on the negligence claim based on the statutory violation. The court found that the plaintiffs failed to provide evidence that the alleged statutory violations proximately caused Sydney's injuries. The plaintiffs appealed, but the Appellate Court of Maryland affirmed the circuit court's decision, agreeing that the plaintiffs did not establish the necessary causation-in-fact.The Supreme Court of Maryland reviewed the case and affirmed the judgment of the Appellate Court. The court held that to establish a prima facie case of negligence based on a statutory violation, the plaintiff must show that the defendant violated a statute designed to protect a specific class of persons that includes the plaintiff and that the violation proximately caused the plaintiff's injury. The court emphasized that proximate cause requires evidence of both causation-in-fact and legal causation. The plaintiffs failed to provide sufficient evidence to establish that the statutory violations were the cause-in-fact of Sydney's injuries, and thus, the summary judgment in favor of the defendants was upheld. View "Walton v. Premier Soccer Club" on Justia Law